“Micky, my engagement on Instagram is dropping drastically – it has fallen by over 50% – what should I do?”
That is a sentence I’ve heard a lot recently, especially from the larger Instagram accounts I manage.
That’s why I decided to investigate the matter more closely.
But is Instagram doing the same?
Apparently, yes – but it has not been confirmed by official sources yet. Instagram has usually updated their blog regularly with updates, but that is not the case this time.
So I looked into the blogs that are usually reliable when it comes to algorithm updates.
Let’s take a look at what has happened and what you can do to maintain your engagement on Instagram.
Organic visibility is dropping
Instagram has experienced massive growth in recent years, and naturally, organic reach on the platform is becoming more limited – similar to what we’ve seen on Google Adwords and Facebook. My guess is that we will see the same on Amazon.
The more users a platform has, the more competition there will be for visibility.
This has consequences.
As more users join, more advertisers also enter the space. So, not only are users competing for visibility, but advertisers are competing for the same spots as well.
Additionally, all social media platforms run on algorithms.
Algorithms are often based on what we like and share. That’s why you may notice seeing lots of cat videos and contests on Facebook.
You can’t afford to be passive
I manage profiles for public figures and celebrities who primarily use Instagram for personal branding, so they are not always very active.
An important point, however, is that YOU must be active. This can be challenging for larger personalities or brands managed by managers who cannot interact authentically as the person behind the profile.
So what do you do?
You need to stay active. It really is that simple. You need to participate like a “normal” user. This means you cannot just exist on the platform. The whole idea behind social media is interaction, so you must engage.
Tips for being active as a brand or personality:
- Comment on the first comments you receive.
- Find people tagging your brand or hashtag, and comment on their posts – be personal, not generic like a “bot.”
- Shout out other users’ posts featuring your products, or photos from events if you are a celebrity. This encourages more sharing and tells Instagram that you’re contributing valuable engagement.
- Connect with people and take photos together to boost mutual activity.
- Be authentic as a brand and as a personality. Whether you are a blogger, musician, brand, or e-commerce store, authenticity matters.
Follow Gary Vaynerchuck on Instagram. Even with over 1 million followers, he often responds to comments or gives away a few shoes to those engaging with his posts.
Hashtags and captions
Hashtags have always been a controversial topic. Recent articles indicate that we should use more targeted hashtags.
I recommend finding niche hashtags rather than the most popular ones. You get lost among millions of posts if you only use the top tags. As a brand or personality, create your own hashtag to start trends others want to follow.
Instagram now allows users to report hashtags – preventing misuse by copycat accounts.
Instagram does not have one algorithm – it has several, and they constantly evolve. What worked yesterday may not work tomorrow. Understanding these algorithms is key to generating reach, engagement, and sales without “fighting” the system.
The algorithm is not one thing – but five systems
Instagram works with multiple systems, each controlling different areas:
- Feed: Main content stream, influenced by relationships and engagement history
- Stories: Prioritizes relationships and recency
- Explore: Content based on interaction and trends
- Reels: Focuses on entertainment value, retention, and new reach
- Search: Keyword-based, increasingly like TikTok search
Each system has its logic and priorities. Content that performs in Reels may not perform in Feed, and vice versa.
How the feed algorithm works
Feed prioritizes your relationship with the user:
- How often they interact with your content
- Whether they have shared, saved, or liked your previous posts
- How much time they spend on your posts
- What they interacted with from similar profiles
This means one good post is not enough. You need ongoing interaction and to keep people engaged longer on your posts.
How the Reels algorithm works
Reels is Instagram’s discovery engine, designed to reach new audiences. It prioritizes:
- Completion rate: Do viewers watch the video to the end?
- Rewatch: Do they watch it again?
- Engagement: Comments, likes, and shares, especially early
- Use of original sounds and effects
Hook viewers within the first 1–2 seconds. Use captions and short formats. Make sound part of the story, not just music.
How the stories algorithm works
Stories prioritize closeness and timeliness. The more you interact with a profile, the higher their story appears. To optimize:
- Post consistently, ideally daily
- Use interactive stickers: polls, questions, quizzes
- Respond to replies to strengthen relationships
Stories build trust and connection rather than going viral.
How Explore and Search work
- Explore: Content shown based on interest and behavior; Meta tests content with small audiences before expanding its reach. Use relevant hashtags, prioritize quality and engagement.
- Search: Users search for inspiration (“tattoo ideas,” “budget recipes”). Include keywords in captions and overlays. Instagram now acts as a visual search engine, with AI increasingly involved.
What Meta rewards and what to avoid
Meta rewards:
- Original content (not TikTok reposts)
- Using platform features (collabs, remixes, stickers)
- Engagement without clickbait
Avoid:
- Reposts with TikTok watermarks
- Misleading text or engagement bait (“Comment YES if you agree”)
- Impersonal or low-quality content
Shadowbanning is rare, but violating guidelines can limit reach without notice. Stick to authentic content.
How to boost reach without compromise
Reach depends on signals, not luck:
- Post when your audience is active (Insights)
- Use carousel posts for longer engagement
- Start posts with strong visual and textual hooks
- Encourage real conversations in comments
- Share posts in stories to amplify reach
You can be strategic without being over-polished. Use data but keep your voice.
The future: AI, Threads, and personalization
Instagram will increasingly adapt to your behavior across platforms, including Threads. AI-driven personalized feeds will show what you interact with across the Meta ecosystem.
Creators must focus on relationships, not just reach: stories → DMs → Reels → feed → profile visits.
Summary: What to focus on
- Understand the difference between feed, reels, explore, stories, and search
- Create original content for each format
- Hook early and keep viewers engaged
- Use platform features and stay active
- Focus on relationships, not just reach
Instagram remains a strong platform – but only if you understand its rules, which change constantly.
FAQ: Instagram algorithm, engagement, and content strategy
My Instagram Reels are getting zero views. How do I write a hook that stops the scroll?
You already know you only have 1 to 2 seconds to grab someone’s attention on Reels, but the real trick is pairing your visuals with on-screen text instantly.
Never kick off a video by saying “Hey, my name is…” instead, jump straight into the action with a bold claim or a visual pattern-interrupt within the first two seconds.
Use an “open loop” text overlay like “The biggest mistake I made with my engagement…”, so curiosity automatically forces them to keep watching for the payoff.
The faster you spark that visual curiosity, the faster your completion rate shoots up, and that’s how you get the algorithm completely on your side.
How do I get people to comment on my Instagram posts instead of just liking and scrolling past?
You need to make commenting a no-brainer by dropping one ultra-simple question at the very end of your caption.
Stop asking broad questions like “What do you think?” and start giving them two clear options instead: “Are you Team A or Team B? Let me know in the comments.”
This immediately breaks the ice in your comment section, boosts your engagement metrics, and the algorithm will absolutely love you for it.
Everyone says carousel posts boost “dwell time” on Instagram. How do I format them, so people swipe through?
When the algorithm looks at your Feed posts, it heavily tracks dwell time, which is how many seconds a user spends hovering over your content instead of scrolling past.
Carousels are your absolute secret weapon here because Instagram usually gives them two chances; if a follower skips past the first slide in the morning, the app will serve them the second slide later that day.
Strategy-wise, build your carousel like a mini-article: Slide 1 is your hook, slides 2 to 4 deliver the actual gold nuggets, and the final slide has a crystal-clear Call-to-Action (CTA) prompting them to comment.
How often do I need to post on Instagram for the algorithm to favor me?
Stop trying to push out deep, heavy posts every single day because quality beats quantity every time with the current algorithm.
Lock in a consistent routine where you drop 2 to 3 Reels a week to reach new eyes, and post 1 high-value carousel for your existing followers.
Your Stories, on the other hand, should be a daily habit, think 3 to 5 quick, raw glimpses into your day.
It takes two minutes, but it keeps your community engaged without forcing you to spend hours in the editing room.
Should I focus on Instagram Reels or regular Feed posts if my main goal is getting more followers?
You need to do both, but you have to use them for completely different jobs because they are run by separate algorithms.
Your Feed and Stories are strictly for keeping your existing audience connected and loyal through interactions and DMs.
Reels, however, are your ultimate growth engine because the algorithm specifically pushes them out to people who don’t know you yet.
If you want new followers, double down on Reels with great hooks; if you want to retain them, nurture them through your Feed and carousels.
Do hashtags still work on Instagram, or should I just focus on Instagram SEO in my captions?
Hashtags aren’t completely dead, but they’ve shifted from being a primary reach tool to acting as a categorization tag for Instagram’s AI.
You need to treat the platform like a visual search engine and focus heavily on Instagram SEO by incorporating relevant keywords into your captions instead.
A good tactic is to write a short, punchy caption at the top, and then hide 4 to 6 specific keywords and niche hashtags at the very bottom after a few line breaks.
This keeps your copy clean for your followers while letting the search algorithm read your keywords and surface your post when people search for your topic.
Comments